Quality of earnings is the accounting test that tells a buyer or seller how much of a business's reported profit is real, recurring and convertible to cash. In an Ontario acquisition, that answer decides how much the business is worth and what the purchase agreement has to say about the numbers.

A quality of earnings review is a transaction-focused accounting analysis that converts reported profit into normalized, sustainable earnings, giving buyers and sellers a tested figure to anchor the purchase price before due diligence turns into signed deal terms. It differs from an audit because it asks whether the earnings will repeat. It differs from a valuation because it supplies the earnings figure that a valuation multiplies.
Many private Ontario companies only have compiled financial statements, which carry no independent verification. That gap is where price disputes, holdback fights and indemnity claims start. At Beganyi Law, our mergers and acquisitions practice works alongside clients' accountants so QoE findings land in the purchase agreement as precise legal terms. If you are preparing to buy or sell, you can reach us at +1 647-977-7749 to talk through how the numbers should shape your deal.
Key Takeaways
- Quality of earnings measures whether profit is sustainable and backed by cash.
- Normalized EBITDA and working capital findings feed directly into price and closing adjustments.
- The accountant tests the numbers, and the transaction lawyer turns them into enforceable protections.
What Makes Reported Earnings Reliable and Repeatable?
Reported earnings are reliable when they come from core business operations, recur under normal conditions and turn into cash. Earnings quality is weaker when profit depends on one-time gains, generous accounting estimates or revenue the company has not yet collected.
How Do High-Quality Earnings Differ from Low-Quality Earnings?
High-quality earnings come from the company's ordinary customers, products and margins. They would show up again next year if nothing unusual happened. Sustainable earnings also carry a realistic cost structure, including a market salary for the owner's role and full staffing.
Low-quality earnings lean on items a buyer cannot count on. Common examples in private company deals include:
- A one-time gain on the sale of equipment booked in operating income
- An unusually large order from a customer who will not reorder
- Understated expenses because a senior position sat vacant
- Reserves released to lift reported net income in the sale year
Each of these inflates reported earnings without improving future financial performance. A buyer paying a multiple on that profit pays the multiple on the inflation too.
Why Can Net Income Differ from Cash Flow?
Accrual accounting records revenue when it is earned and expenses when they are incurred, regardless of when cash moves. A $1 million sale on 30-day terms shows up as income immediately. If the customer pays late, or not at all, the profit sits in receivables.
This is why a business can report steady profit while the bank balance shrinks. Rising receivables, inventory build-up and unrecorded accruals all widen the gap between reported net income and cash. A QoE analysis reconciles the two so the buyer sees how much profit lands in the bank.
How Does a QoE Report Differ from an Audit or Valuation?
Each engagement answers a different question:
Engagement | Core question | Output | Assurance |
|---|---|---|---|
Audit | Are the financial statements fairly presented under the accounting standards? | Opinion on statements | Reasonable |
Review engagement | Is anything plausibly wrong with the statements? | Limited conclusion | Limited |
Quality of earnings | What earnings can this business keep producing? | Adjusted earnings and findings | None (consulting work) |
Valuation | What is the business worth? | Fair market value conclusion | Valuator's opinion |
An audit tests compliance with frameworks such as IFRS, ASPE or U.S. GAAP and focuses heavily on the balance sheet. A QoE study focuses on economic earnings and uses a much lower materiality threshold. When a formal fair market value opinion is needed, a Chartered Business Valuator prepares it, and the QoE figure becomes the tested starting point for that company valuation.
What Does a Transaction-Focused QoE Report Examine?
A quality of earnings report walks from reported profit to adjusted EBITDA one documented adjustment at a time. Along the way it tests revenue streams, accounting policies and the supporting records behind every add-back.
How Is EBITDA Normalized for Sustainable Operations?
Normalizing earnings starts with EBITDA from the income statement and removes items that will not continue after closing. Sellers present their own add-backs; the buyer's accountant tests each one against invoices, payroll records and the general ledger.
Typical normalization adjustments include:
- Owner compensation: replacing the owner's actual pay and perks with the market cost of hiring someone to do the job.
- Related-party items: adjusting rent paid to the owner's holding company to an arm's-length rate.
- Nonrecurring items: removing a lawsuit settlement, a one-off consulting project or one-time gains.
- Personal expenses: removing vehicles, travel or family payroll run through the business.
- Pro forma changes: annualizing a mid-year rent increase or a new wage agreement.
Adjustments run in both directions. A seller's claimed cost reduction that has not yet taken effect may be reversed, and an unfilled role may be added back as an expense, lowering adjusted EBITDA.
Which Revenue Streams Are Recurring and Likely to Continue?
Recurring earnings come from contracts, subscriptions, repeat customers and maintenance work that continue without a fresh sales effort. Project revenue and one-off orders carry more risk, even when they are profitable.
A QoE analysis breaks revenue and gross margin down by customer and by product or service line. If three customers produce half the profit, their contract terms, renewal dates and change-of-control clauses move to the top of the diligence list. That link between financial findings and contract review is a core part of due diligence for an Ontario acquisition.
Which Accounting Policies and Estimates Need Closer Review?
Accounting policies and accounting estimates give management room to move profit between periods. The areas we see scrutinized most often in private deals are:
- Revenue recognition policies: whether revenue is booked when goods or services are delivered, or earlier. Aggressive revenue recognition, such as booking percentage-of-completion revenue ahead of the work, pulls future profit into the sale year.
- Depreciation methods: whether fixed assets are depreciated over realistic lives, and whether maintenance capital spending was deferred before the sale.
- Cut-off: whether income and expenses at year-end sit in the correct period.
- Reserves and accruals: whether bad debt, warranty and inventory reserves changed without an operational reason.
Conservative accounting policies tend to understate profit, while aggressive accounting overstates it. Earnings manipulation in small businesses rarely looks dramatic; it usually shows up as small accounting adjustments that all push in the same direction. Non-cash items deserve the same attention because they move EBITDA without moving cash.
What Records Should Buyers and Sellers Prepare?
The accountant needs ledger-level data, not summary statements. A standard request list includes:
- At least three years of financial statements and corporate tax returns
- The general ledger, trial balances and bank statements
- Monthly results since the last year-end
- Receivables and payables aging reports
- GST/HST and payroll filings
- Key customer, supplier and lease contracts
- A schedule of related-party transactions and personal expenses
Sellers who assemble this before going to market answer buyer questions faster and defend their numbers more credibly. Our sell-side representation work includes organizing corporate records and the minute book alongside the financial package, since buyers request both.
How Do Cash Conversion and Working Capital Test Earnings?
Cash conversion is the most direct test of earnings quality: if adjusted profit does not appear in operating cash flow over time, something in the cash cycle is absorbing it. Working capital analysis shows where that cash is trapped and how much the buyer must fund after closing.
How Is the Quality of Earnings Ratio Calculated?
The quality of earnings ratio compares cash from operations to net income:
QoE ratio = operating cash flow ÷ net income
A ratio at or above 1.0 means reported profit is converting into cash. A ratio persistently below 1.0 means earnings are accumulating as receivables, inventory or other non-cash balances.
The accruals ratio looks at the same issue from the balance sheet side, measuring how much of earnings comes from changes in accrued balances. A high accruals ratio signals that profit depends more on accounting entries than on cash collected. Both figures come from the cash flow statement and comparative balance sheets.
What Can Receivables, Inventory, and Payables Reveal?
Each working capital account tells its own story about future earnings and cash flows:
- Accounts receivable: receivables growing faster than sales point to slow-paying customers, extended credit terms or revenue booked too early. The aging report shows whether old balances should be written off.
- Inventory: rising inventory without matching sales growth suggests slow-moving or obsolete stock.
- Payables and accruals: stretching suppliers before a sale inflates cash temporarily. Unrecorded liabilities, such as bonuses recorded only when paid, flatter both earnings and net working capital.
These findings matter twice: once for adjusted earnings and again for the working capital level the buyer expects at closing.
Why Do Ratio Trends Matter More Than a Single Result?
A single year's ratio can mislead. A seasonal business that closes its year at peak receivables will show weak cash conversion that reverses a quarter later.
Accountants look at monthly net working capital (NWC) over 12 to 24 months to separate seasonality from deterioration. Working capital trends that worsen steadily as a sale approaches are a classic warning sign. Those same monthly averages become the basis for the closing target discussed in our article on working capital adjustment calculations and deal terms. Deals priced through a locked box mechanism depend on this historical analysis even more, because there is no post-closing true-up.
How Do QoE Findings Shape Price and Legal Protections?
QoE findings change the deal in four places: the headline purchase price, the working capital mechanism, the seller's warranties and indemnities, and the division of work between advisors. Each finding should end up in a specific clause.
How Can Earnings Adjustments Change the Purchase Price?
Private businesses are commonly priced as a multiple of adjusted EBITDA, so every adjustment is multiplied. If diligence reduces adjusted EBITDA by $150,000 and the agreed multiple is 4x, the implied company valuation falls by $600,000.
Buyers use findings to renegotiate after the letter of intent. Where earnings are real but uncertain (a new contract, a recovering product line), parties often bridge the gap with deferred consideration. An earnout structure ties part of the price to future earnings, and its definitions should mirror the accounting policies tested in the QoE.
How Should Working Capital Targets and Closing Adjustments Be Defined?
The agreement should set a net working capital target, often called the peg, based on normalized historical averages. If closing working capital falls short, the price drops dollar for dollar; if it exceeds the peg, the seller may receive more, depending on the drafting.
The definitions carry the risk. The agreement needs to specify:
- Which accounts are included and excluded (cash and debt are usually excluded)
- The accounting policies used to measure closing balances, matched to those in the QoE
- How debt-like items such as customer deposits, deferred revenue and unpaid bonuses are treated, counted once and never twice
- Timelines and a dispute process involving an independent accountant
How Do Findings Inform Warranties, Disclosures, and Indemnities?
Every QoE finding becomes either a disclosure or a protection. Known issues go into the disclosure schedules, and the buyer negotiates a specific indemnity for them, such as unremitted payroll deductions or GST/HST exposure. Unknown risks are covered by the seller's representations and warranties about financial statements, liabilities and accounting policies.
Holdbacks and escrow give those promises teeth. Sellers benefit too: disclosing an issue clearly limits later claims. Weak corporate governance or missing records in the minute book also surface here and may require closing conditions.
What Do the Accountant and Transaction Lawyer Each Handle?
The roles are distinct and should be coordinated from the start.
Accountant | Transaction lawyer |
|---|---|
Tests revenue, expenses and add-backs | Drafts the letter of intent and purchase agreement |
Calculates adjusted EBITDA and the peg | Defines EBITDA, working capital and debt in the contract |
Identifies tax and remittance exposures | Negotiates warranties, indemnities and holdbacks |
Reconciles earnings to cash | Reviews contracts, corporate records and litigation |
Because our team combines tax and corporate experience, we read QoE reports with an eye to how each finding affects both the legal terms and the tax result of the deal.
Turn Earnings Findings into Clear Deal Terms
A quality of earnings review is most valuable when its numbers flow directly into the purchase agreement. Sustainable earnings set the purchase price. Working capital analysis sets the peg. Each exception found in due diligence becomes a disclosure, a warranty or a specific indemnity.
For buyers, the practical sequence looks like this:
- Obtain the seller's last two to three years of statements before signing the letter of intent.
- Engage an accountant to test add-backs, revenue quality and cash conversion.
- Have your lawyer convert adjusted EBITDA, working capital and debt definitions into contract language.
- Match every finding to a price change, a closing adjustment or a protection.
For sellers, a sell-side review lets you correct problems and document add-backs before a buyer's team finds them. Our M&A due diligence work connects these findings to the transaction documents, with principal lawyer Ladislav Beganyi completing more than 20 commercial transactions each year and coordinating closely with clients' accountants.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need a QoE report when buying a small Ontario business?
Most buyers benefit from some form of QoE analysis, especially when the target only has compiled statements. For smaller deals, a narrower scope focused on a proof of cash, add-backs and working capital can be enough. Specialized sectors such as dental practice transactions still call for testing revenue by provider and payer.
Should a seller commission a QoE report before going to market?
Yes, when the business has meaningful add-backs, related-party items or uneven results. A sell-side report lets you defend adjusted earnings in negotiations and shortens buyer due diligence. It fits naturally into a broader exit strategy for a business sale.
How much does a quality of earnings report cost?
Canadian advisors commonly quote roughly $20,000 to $40,000 or more for a comprehensive QoE on a larger or complex acquisition, and roughly $5,000 to $20,000 for narrower financial due diligence on smaller deals. Messy books, multiple entities and rushed timelines push fees higher. Ask for a scoped quote based on your deal size.
How long does a quality of earnings review take?
A focused QoE analysis commonly takes two to four weeks once the data room is complete. Delays in producing the general ledger, bank statements or aging reports extend that timeline. Build the review period into your letter of intent exclusivity window.
Can a buyer rely on the seller's QoE report?
A buyer can use a seller's quality of earnings report as a starting point, though it was prepared for the seller's purposes. Most buyers, and their lenders, still test the key adjustments independently. Reliance letters and the seller's financial warranties determine what legal recourse exists if the report proves wrong.
