Two business professionals review and exchange company documents at a conference table.

Business Law

Section 86 Rollover: Ontario Rules, Steps, and Tax Pitfalls

15 min readBeganyi Professional Corporation

A section 86 rollover lets a shareholder swap one class of shares for new shares of the same corporation without triggering immediate tax. Owners use it to freeze value, change voting control, or make room for new shareholders, all inside the existing company. The rules are short, but small drafting errors can turn a planned tax deferral into a capital gain or a deemed dividend.

Two business professionals review and exchange company documents at a conference table.

A share exchange qualifies under section 86 of the Income Tax Act when, as part of a reorganization of the corporation's capital, a shareholder disposes of all of their shares of a class (held as capital property) and receives consideration from the same corporation that includes new shares; the rollover then applies automatically, with no election form. Tax deferral holds as long as any cash or note does not exceed the cost and paid-up capital of the old shares and the new shares carry full value.

At Beganyi Professional Corporation, we design and implement tax-driven reorganizations for Ontario owners, coordinating the corporate filings with the accountant's numbers so the documents and the tax result line up. If you are weighing a share exchange, you can call us at +1 647-977-7749 or book a confidential consultation, including remote meetings for clients anywhere in Ontario.

Key Takeaways

  • Section 86 applies automatically when all of a shareholder's shares of one class are exchanged for new shares of the same corporation.
  • Cash or notes above the old shares' cost or paid-up capital can trigger a capital gain or deemed dividend.
  • Accurate valuation, a price adjustment clause, and proper Ontario corporate approvals protect the deferral.

When Does an Internal Share Exchange Qualify?

An internal exchange qualifies when four conditions line up: a capital reorganization, a disposition of every share of the class the shareholder owns, shares held as capital property, and new shares issued by the same corporation. Each condition has practical traps, and the order of priority between sections 85, 86, and 51 decides which rule governs.

What Counts as a Reorganization of Capital?

Section 86 requires the exchange to happen "in the course of a reorganization of the capital of a corporation." The Income Tax Act does not define that phrase. In practice, the CRA accepts a reorganization when the corporation's capital structure changes, most commonly through articles of amendment that create a new class of shares or alter the rights of existing ones.

In our files, the cleanest approach is to amend the articles first, then complete the exchange under a written agreement that refers to the reorganization. An exchange of shares done informally, with no change to the share structure and no supporting resolutions, invites an argument that no capital reorganization took place.

The old shares must also be capital property to the shareholder. Shares held as inventory (for example, by a trader) fall outside the rule.

Which Shares Must the Shareholder Exchange?

The shareholder must dispose of all the shares of the particular class they own at that moment. If an owner holds 100 Class A common shares, exchanging 60 and keeping 40 fails the test.

The requirement applies shareholder by shareholder, so one owner can reorganize while another keeps their shares untouched. Different classes are tested separately: an owner holding both common and Class B shares can exchange only the common shares.

Where an owner wants to keep part of a class, the usual fix is to exchange the entire class and receive a mix of new shares, such as fixed-value preferred shares plus a small number of new common shares.

What Consideration Must Come From the Same Corporation?

The property received must be "receivable from the corporation" and must include other shares of that corporation's capital stock. A share-for-share exchange with the same company satisfies this. Shares of a parent, sister, or holding company do not.

The consideration can also include non-share property, such as cash or a promissory note, alongside the new shares. That boot does not disqualify the rollover, but it changes the tax math, as discussed below.

Section 86 itself does not require a Canadian corporation or a taxable Canadian corporation. The deemed dividend rules that interact with it apply to corporations resident in Canada, which covers the Ontario corporations we work with.

When Do Sections 51 or 85 Apply Instead?

Section 85 takes priority. Subsection 86(3) switches off section 86 whenever a joint election under subsection 85(1) applies. Section 85 requires a transfer to a taxable Canadian corporation and a filed Form T2057, and it lets the parties pick an elected amount. Our practical guide to section 85 rollovers covers that election in detail.

Section 51 sits below both. Subsection 51(4) states that section 51 does not apply where section 85 or 86 applies. Section 51 covers conversions of shares, bonds, or debentures of a corporation into shares of the same corporation, and only where no consideration other than the share is received.

Feature

Section 85

Section 86

Section 51

Election required

Yes, Form T2057

No

No

Transferee

Taxable Canadian corporation

Same corporation

Same corporation

Must exchange whole class

No

Yes

No

Boot allowed

Yes

Yes

No

Choose transfer amount

Yes

No

No

When an owner needs to control the exact gain (for example, to use an exemption), section 85 is the better tool. When the goal is a clean deferral with minimal paperwork, section 86 fits, and choosing between them is part of sound business structuring.

How Do Share Values and Consideration Affect the Tax Result?

Under section 86, the tax result follows a formula: the old shares' adjusted cost base moves to the new shares, reduced by any boot, and the proceeds equal whatever cost the shareholder receives. Paid-up capital is ground down so it cannot exceed what the old shares carried, and any value shift to a related person can trigger immediate tax.

How Do ACB and Paid-Up Capital Carry Forward?

Paragraph 86(1)(b) sets the cost of the new shares at the old shares' total ACB minus the fair market value of any non-share consideration. Where the shareholder receives more than one class of new shares, that cost is allocated in proportion to each class's FMV immediately after the exchange.

Paragraph 86(1)(c) deems the proceeds of disposition of the old shares to equal the cost of the new shares plus the boot. In a share-only exchange, proceeds equal ACB, so no capital gain or capital loss arises.

Subsection 86(2.1) limits paid-up capital. If the corporation adds more to the stated capital of the new shares than the PUC of the old shares (less boot), the excess is deducted for tax purposes. This prevents owners from creating extra PUC that could later be withdrawn tax-free.

When Can Boot Trigger a Capital Gain or Deemed Dividend?

Boot creates two separate exposures:

  • Deemed dividend: The corporation is treated as having acquired the old shares. Under subsection 84(3), any amount paid above the PUC of those shares is a deemed dividend. Boot that exceeds the old shares' PUC produces dividend income.
  • Capital gain: If boot exceeds the old shares' ACB, the new shares get a nil cost and the proceeds exceed ACB. The Act reduces proceeds by any deemed dividend so the same dollars are not taxed twice, but a gain remains possible where ACB is lower than PUC.

For most owner-managers with nominal ACB and PUC (often $1 or $100), the safest course is to limit boot to the lower of those two figures.

A Share-Only Exchange Example With FMV, ACB, and Paid-Up Capital

Assume an owner holds 100 common shares of an Ontario company:

Item

Old common shares

New preferred shares

Fair market value

$2,000,000

$2,000,000 (redemption value)

Adjusted cost base

$100

$100

Paid-up capital

$100

$100 (after 86(2.1) grind)

Boot received

None

None

Proceeds equal the $100 cost of the new shares, so the gain is nil. If the company's resolution had set the stated capital of the preferred shares at $500,000, subsection 86(2.1) would still reduce tax PUC to $100.

Now add a $300,000 promissory note. The new shares' cost drops to nil, and roughly $299,900 becomes a deemed dividend under subsection 84(3). That one change converts a tax-free reorganization into a large income inclusion in the year of the exchange.

Why Do Valuation Errors and Related-Person Benefits Matter?

Subsection 86(2) applies when the old shares' FMV exceeds the boot plus the new shares' FMV, and the excess can reasonably be seen as a benefit the shareholder wanted to confer on a related person. Proceeds are then increased by this "gift portion," any capital loss is denied, and the new shares' cost is reduced. The owner pays tax and gets lower cost going forward.

The classic case is an owner who exchanges common shares worth $2,000,000 for preferred shares worth $1,500,000 while their children hold new common shares. The missing $500,000 is a gift portion.

A price adjustment clause is the standard protection. The CRA's Income Tax Folio S4-F3-C1 recognizes these clauses for subsection 86(2) when the parties intend a fair market value transfer, use a fair and reasonable method, agree to adopt any value set by the CRA or a court, and actually adjust the price. A defensible business valuation supports the first two conditions.

How Is the Exchange Implemented Under Ontario Corporate Law?

Implementation in Ontario runs through the Ontario Business Corporations Act (OBCA): approve the share changes, file articles of amendment, sign the exchange documents, and update the corporate minute book. The steps below follow the order we use on most files.

Review the Existing Share Rights and Required Approvals

Start with the current articles, the minute book, and any unanimous shareholder agreement or shareholder agreement. Confirm who holds which shares, what share classes exist, and whether the new class can be issued without an amendment.

Creating a new class or changing share rights requires a special resolution under OBCA section 168. A special resolution means at least two-thirds of the votes cast at a duly called meeting, or written consent from every shareholder entitled to vote. Section 170 can also give an affected class a separate class vote, even if that class is otherwise non-voting.

Check for financing covenants or consent rights that restrict changes to the capital structure. Lenders sometimes require notice of any capital reorganization.

Prepare and File Any Required Articles of Amendment

Articles of amendment set out the rights, privileges, restrictions, and conditions of the new shares. For freeze-style preferred shares, that usually includes:

  • A fixed redemption and retraction amount tied to FMV at the exchange date
  • A price adjustment clause
  • Dividend entitlement (often non-cumulative, at the directors' discretion)
  • Voting rights, if the owner is keeping control
  • Liquidation priority over the common shares

Articles of amendment are filed through the Ontario Business Registry. The government fee for an amendment filed online is $150, and online filings are processed immediately; mailed filings take 15 business days. The amendment takes effect on the date in the certificate, so the exchange must be dated on or after that date.

Document the Exchange and Update the Corporate Records

A section 86 rollover agreement (or share exchange agreement) records which old shares are surrendered, which new shares are issued, the agreed FMV, any boot, and the price adjustment mechanism.

Supporting documents include directors' resolutions authorizing the issuance and fixing the stated capital of the new shares, a resolution reducing stated capital where needed, cancellation of the old share certificates, issuance of new share certificates, and updated securities and shareholder registers. The minute book should read as a complete, consistent record; buyers and the CRA will both review it.

Coordinate Tax Reporting Without a Section 86 Election

No election is filed for section 86. Form T2057 belongs to section 85, and filing it would bring section 85 into play and displace section 86 under subsection 86(3).

The shareholder still reports the disposition of the old shares on their return. The corporation's accountant records the PUC grind and, where boot exceeds PUC, issues a T5 slip for the deemed dividend. We share the final documents with the client's accountant so the tax schedules match the legal record.

Where Does the Reorganization Fit in Your Ownership Plan?

Section 86 is the mechanical tool behind several common ownership changes: freezing value, shifting control, and preparing for a holding company or sale. It works best when the exchange is planned as one step in a broader structure.

Using Fixed-Value Shares for Succession Without Rebuilding the Entire Plan

The most common use is an internal estate freeze. The owner exchanges common shares for fixed-value preferred shares, and new common shares are issued to children or a family trust at a nominal price. Future growth accrues to the new common shareholders.

Because section 86 works inside the existing company, there is no need to incorporate a new entity or move assets. The design questions are the preferred share terms, the price adjustment clause, and who subscribes for the new common shares. Attribution rules and the trust deed need separate review where minors or a spouse benefit.

Adjusting Voting Rights and Accommodating New Owners

Owners also use section 86 to separate value from control. A founder can exchange voting common shares for voting preferred shares, keeping control while allowing key employees or a partner to subscribe for non-voting or voting common shares.

Bringing in a new owner often requires a shareholder agreement update at the same time. Transfer restrictions, buy-sell triggers, and dividend policy all change once there are two classes with different economic interests.

Coordinating Holding Company and Future Sale Planning

Section 86 cannot move shares to a holding company; that transfer uses section 85. In practice, the two are combined: an owner first reorganizes under section 86, then transfers the new shares to a holding company under section 85.

For a future sale, timing matters for the lifetime capital gains exemption. Section 86 rollovers defer gains automatically and give no way to elect a higher amount, so crystallizing the exemption usually runs through a section 85 election. The holding period and asset tests for qualified small business corporation shares also need to be reviewed before any shares change hands.

Align Your Share Exchange With Your Business and Tax Goals

A section 86 exchange delivers tax-deferred results when every condition is met: a genuine capital reorganization, all shares of the class exchanged, consideration from the same corporation, and boot kept within the old shares' cost and PUC. Valuation backed by a price adjustment clause guards against subsection 86(2), and the OBCA steps make the exchange legally effective.

At Beganyi Law, principal lawyer Ladislav Beganyi brings an LL.B., a Master of Taxation, and a B.B.A. to this work, and completes more than 20 commercial transactions each year. We handle the corporate reorganization documents and the tax planning together, working with your accountant so the share terms match the numbers.

If the exchange is part of a longer transition, link it to your broader business succession planning before the articles are filed. Our office is open Monday to Friday, 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM, at +1 647-977-7749.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do all shareholders have to participate in a section 86 rollover?

No. The all-shares test applies to each shareholder individually, so one owner can exchange their entire class while others keep their shares. The corporate approvals, such as a special resolution and any class vote, may still require other shareholders' consent.

Can I keep some shares of the class I am exchanging?

No, keeping any shares of that class disqualifies the exchange under section 86. You can exchange the full class and take back a combination of new shares, such as preferred shares plus a small number of new common shares, to achieve the same economic result.

Does receiving cash or a promissory note disqualify the rollover?

No, non-share consideration is permitted as long as some new shares are also received. Boot above the old shares' paid-up capital creates a deemed dividend, and boot above their adjusted cost base can produce a capital gain.

Can I use section 86 to transfer shares to a holding company?

No, section 86 only covers exchanges with the corporation that issued the old shares. A transfer to a holding company uses a section 85 election with Form T2057, sometimes as a second step after a section 86 reorganization.

Does a section 86 rollover automatically qualify me for the lifetime capital gains exemption?

No. Section 86 defers the gain and leaves the exemption untouched; eligibility depends on the qualified small business corporation share tests at the time of sale. Owners who want to crystallize the exemption usually use a section 85 election to set the amount.

What determines the cost and timing of an Ontario share reorganization?

The main drivers are the complexity of the share terms, whether a formal valuation is needed, and the number of shareholders who must approve. The Ontario government fee for articles of amendment filed online is $150 with immediate processing, so drafting and coordination with your accountant set most of the timeline.

Written by

Beganyi Professional Corporation

Book a Consultation
← Back to All Insights